winething9

JANUARY 17, 2009 VINTAGES RELEASE

 

SUGGESTIONS

85001 - 2006 Domaine Pardon Fleurie - $20.95 - #1 PICK  Reasons : (1) Silver medal; (2) Michael Vaughan 2 stars & Recommendation; (3) Billy Munnelly selection : [P#1 / D#1]

32094 - 2005 Don Eugenio Reserva Cabernet Sauvignon - $13.95 - PICK  Reasons : (1) Gordon Stimmell 89 points & Best Value Red; (2) Rod Phillips 4 stars; (3) Michael Vaughan 1 1/2 stars (out of 3) ; (4) Dean Tudor 93 points : [P#1 / D#1]

606236 - 2007 d'Arenberg The Stump Jump Grenache Shiraz Mourvedre - $14.95 - PICK  Reasons : (1) 88 points Jay Miller (Robert Parker's Wine Advocate), (2) 88 points Josh Raynolds (Stephen Tanzer's International Wine Cellar(, (3) 4 1/2 stars Paddy Kendler (Herald Sun), (4) 2 stars (out of 3) Michael Vaughan (Vintage Assessments)  [P#1, D#1]

93880 - 2006 Santa Ana La Mascota Malbec - $15.95 - PICK  Reasons : (1) Silver - 2008 IWSC; (2) David Lawrason 90 points; (3) Michael Vaughan 2 stars; (4) Dean Tudor 90 points : [P#9 / D#1]

711705 - 2006 Trumpeter Malbec - $13.95 - PICK  Reasons : (1) Wine Spectator 89 points & Best Value; (2) Jay Miller 87 points; (3) Michael Vaughan 1 1/2 - 2 stars & Best Buy; (4) David Lawrason 86 points : [P#12 / D#1]

2014 - 2005 Clos des Andes - $29.95 -   Reasons : (1) Wine Spectator 89 points; (2) Jay Miller 91 points; (3) Josh Raynolds 90 points; (4) Michael Vaughan 2 stars; (5) 80 year old vines; Previously listed in January 2008 CLASSICS catalogue at $25 - sold out. : [P#~ / D#3]

591743 - 2008 Lurton Reserva Chardonnay - $14.95 - PICK  Reasons :     [P#2 / D#1]

80176 - 2005 Bradgate Stellenbosch Syrah - $13.95 - PICK  Reasons : (1) 87 points from Wine Spectator   [P#2 / D#1]