Knowing that good advice is scarce for the beginning adult skater, I have tried to put some together for you here. This will be a series of notes and notions that I personally believe. Others may disagree, since there are as many ways to be a skater as there are skaters. However, when you are just beginning, sometimes it helps to have someone say, “this is the way it is.”
So here goes.
good skates will not make you a good skater, but bad skates are almost guaranteed to keep you from becoming a good skater.
BOOTS.
Right now you are probably skating in rentals, and wondering if figure skating is worth the agony. If you’re going to keep skating in rentals forever, it probably isn’t. You’ll quit before a year is up. My advice is to spend your first few class sessions (generally 3 to 10 weeks each) in rentals, then make a decision about whether you can see yourself someday attempting a single or double jump and a fast spin, or maybe even ice dancing, in spite of the fact that your feet are killing you right now and you can’t find your balance to save your life. If you decide the answer is “yes, I want to do that stuff,” it’s time to invest in some serious skates. There is no way around this. Some kids can do double jumps in rentals, but adults generally cannot (I did see a 20-something elite skater teach pair skating in a set of rented hockey skates, but that’s entirely another matter).
how to buy serious skates. First, if you are fortunate enough to have a competent pro shop around you, go there. Do not attempt to buy your first pair of serious skates via mail order (or especially not sites like Ebay) unless you must. The reason for this is that figure skates do not fit like street shoes; also, your size can vary widely not only from street shoes, but between different brands of figure skates. You really need to be fitted in person by someone who knows what they are doing.
If money is an issue, or if you don’t want to spend the time, money and effort to put together your first serious pair of new skates before you’re absolutely certain you’ll stick with the sport for a long time, your pro shop may have resources to help find you a pair of used skates. Don’t hesitate to inquire.
Also keep in mind that if you go out and buy, for instance, SP Super-Teri's with Pattern 99 blades, and then you decide that you don't like skating very much after all, you haven't wasted your money. You'll always have a great pair of skates available when you do want to go out to the rink, and if you want to sell them, you can get back some of the money you spent. So nothing is really lost.
The fact is, A SERIOUS ADULT SKATER NEEDS GOOD, SUPPORTIVE, WELL-FITTED BOOTS. Your boots should fit exactly from the tips of your toes to the back of your heel, and your toes should lay naturally in the boot and not feel cramped in any way (yet you should not be able to wiggle them freely). If you have a high arch, there should be support underneath it. You don't want the boots with the blades bolted on because these are always cheapie "beginner blades" and can never be removed. The boots they are attached to usually aren't that great, either. Also, blades don't last forever (more on that in the "Blades" section below), and for adults, boots sometimes do.
Which are good boots? Some brands available in the U.S. are SP Teri, Jackson, Graf, Harlick, and Riedell (be aware that many of these manufacturers also sell recreational boot/bolted-on blade combos – the very thing I just advised you to avoid).
In most product lines, the most expensive stock boots tend to be the ultra-stiff ones that are meant for triple-jumping teens and elite twenty-somethings. You most likely want the boots in the low-middle to the middle of the line, and that leaves you with lots of choices.
As of 2008, these are some examples of good boot choices (and please remember that this list is by no means all-inclusive, these are just examples):
Riedell
Bronze Medallion: beginner or very lightweight skater and/or some ice dancers; very low-cut boot not recommended for those with ankle issues; this is often sold as a boot-blade "set" with a removeable beginner blade
Silver Medallion: beginner to low intermediate; often sold as a boot-removeable blade "set"
Gold Medallion: beginner to intermediate; often sold as a boot-removeable blade "set"
Bronze Star: beginner to intermediate, or heavier skater; no blade attached
Silver Star: intermediate, heavier, or stronger skater; no blade attached
Jackson
Freestyle: beginner or lightweight skater; this is a boot-blade "set" with a removeable beginner blade
Competitor: beginner to intermediate; this is a boot-blade "set" with an Ultima freestyle blade
Elite: intermediate to advanced, or heavier/stronger skater; no blade attached
SP Teri
Pro Teri: beginner to intermediate; no blade attached
Graf
Ace: beginner to intermediate; possibly womens' and girls' sizes only; no blade attached
Harlick
Classic: beginner; no blade attached
Competitor: beginner to intermediate; no blade attached
M
An aside for those of us with a lot of foot to stand on: some narrow-footed, dainty-piggied skaters giggle that Riedells and Jacksons look like baby booties. Don't let that influence you. Just get to be the gigglers' friend -- and then tell them to shut up and mind their own business. Answer any questions about your boot size with raised eyebrows. It takes a while to train these people, but eventually they do catch on that they're being rude. 
Back to boot buying. Try on lots of boots before you decide which pair may be for you. Accept the possibility of making costly mistakes because, unfortunately, that’s part of the sport. I’ve run into very few serious adult skaters who haven’t had equipment issues now and then, but if you take note of what I’m saying here, you may be able to avoid a few common errors.
Hinged boots: I'm updating this paragraph as of 2008. There are, as far as I know, two different hinged boots on the market: Jackson's Proflex (which comes in two styles -- one for highly advanced skaters and the other for more intermediate skaters), and Graf's F-4000 (actually the Graf boot does not appear to have an actual "hinge," but instead a modified, extra-long flex notch). If these boots are successful, expect to see more versions of this idea from other manufacturers; eventually all boots may have some variation of a "hinge," just as many boots nowadays are heat-moldable and have flex notches -- which were the latest innovations included only in the top-of-the-line boots about 5-10 years ago.
I can find no professional review of the F-4000, which does not yet appear to be readily available in the U.S. But for a review of the Proflex, see http://figureskating.about.com/od/bootsandblades/gr/proflex.htm
Hinged boots, which are a fairly recent innovation, remain expensive and controversial. For the adult beginner -- if your coach is not insisting on hinged boots -- I'd advise a wait-and-see attitude; the only exception I can think of would be for a new skater who has very weak ankles. Otherwise, if you want more flexibility in your boots and they do not have a flex-notch (a V-shaped cut at the ankle area where the laces are), have one put in.
The Cement-Boot Syndrome
Again, back to boot buying. When I started skating as an adult, triple-layered (very, very stiff) boots were chic among advanced adult skaters in my area. Those boots, although they were some of the best available, were famously difficult to break in because they were so stiff. But this was in the last few days before the dangers of ultra-stiff skating boots were fully realized, so some of us less-advanced skaters came to believe that owning top-of-the-line boots made us seem more advanced than we were. Others felt that the boots would help them with physical problems, such as bad knees and weak ankles.
How wrong we were. In the early years of the 2000's, as female elite skaters were pushed for triple-triple jump combos and male elite skaters went wild with the quads, top skaters began suffering injuries from the same cement boots that were created to support them on their jump landings. One elite skater in particular was closely associated with a major boot manufacturer, and the boot manufacturer took a bit of a hit to its reputation after this skater suffered a career-ending, boot-induced injury. It was a shame because it wasn't really the boot manufacturer's fault; it was just that the best technology available at the time wasn't keeping pace with the evolution of figure skating.
As this was happening, I started to notice that a few beginner-intermediate adult skating friends were giving up on their cement boots (and sometimes on skating) because they could not break them in. Some others were giving up skating because they'd bought "beginner boots" that did not meet their needs, and were reluctant to buy more expensive, higher-level boots, not only because of the expense but because they'd heard about the horrors of breaking them in. As for myself, I found that the middle-of-the-line boots I owned at the time were actually too much boot for me. I'd chosen them because of my weak ankles, and also because the lower-level boots at the time did not yet have the comfort features of rolled cuffs, heavy padding, heat-moldability and flex notches.
It took a while for the lesson to sink in with both skaters and manufacturers, but eventually the truth became apparent: a too-stiff pair of boots can be harmful. This remains a dilemma for elite skaters doing triples and quads, but for the rest of us the picture is now clearer and the choices far more varied. Even better, all those comfort features that used to be installed only on the heavy-duty boots now come standard on more modest models.
In the beginning, it all depends on your weight. If you are light, you can get lighter boots (there are some good "skate sets" offered by top brands, with the blades SCREWED on, not BOLTED on -- which is necessary because you'll want to get rid of those flat, teensy-picked "beginner blades" very fast). If you are at an ideal weight, or are heavy, the middle-of-the-line boots may suit you -- these are often (but not always) the lowest-priced model in the line of boots without the blades already attached. If you are extremely strong and/or heavy, maybe the top-of-the-line triple-layered ultra-stiff boots can be of some use. But I'd hazard a guess that not many adult beginners are in the last category.
What is never true is that heavy-duty boots will help support bad knees. They may be of some help to weak ankles (although I'd look into the hinged boots rather than the regular top-of-the-line boots for that problem). But if a joint is painful, they will not help and may even do more damage. The rule to remember is that you must be able to bend the boots.
Ultra-stiff boots are meant to help a skater’s body absorb the landing of a triple or quad jump, much the way the hard toe box and shank of a pointe shoe supports a ballet dancer’s foot and (usually) helps keep the toes and metatarsals from breaking under the unnatural stress of standing on tiptoe. Most adult skaters never have to deal with the prospect of doing triple or quad jumps, and so most of us will never have a need for that kind of support.
Still think you need the heavy-duty boots? Read on: ultra-stiff boots can cause skin problems, cysts, bone spurs, ankle injuries, tendonitis, knee problems, hip problems, muscle atrophy, etc. If you buy boots like this as a beginner, you may never learn to skate properly simply because you have to be incredibly strong to get the boots to bend, which is what you must do so you utilize the entire blade, but stay off your picks. Since most adult skaters have knee-bending issues throughout our careers -- we tend not to bend our knees enough and our ankles at all -- a too-stiff pair of boots will only reinforce bad habits.
Custom Boots
Also avoid custom boots, because they are extremely expensive and you do not know what your custom needs are right now -- unless, of course, you have specific instructions from a health care professional (or a very unusual foot). Even then, if a professional suggests orthotics for you, I’ve heard more than once that the orthotics that are built into custom boots are often inferior to the ones available from vendors specializing in orthotics and orthopedic shoes. It’s probably better to buy a pair of orthotics from a specialty shop and just slip them into your stock boots. Be sure to bring your orthotics along when you go to the shop for a fitting, though, because even a thin orthotic can cause discomfort if the fit of the boot does not allow for it.
All in all, custom boots seem to be a waste of time for a beginner with average feet, unless you have your heart set on blue suede or whatever. In that case, go for it.
Keep this in mind during your fitting:
Regardless of their stiffness, expect new boots to hurt. If they hurt too much and you can't find a pair that don't hurt, and you're sure the fit is correct, have the boots punched out or stretched at painful points.
But remember that good figure skates always hurt a bit, especially at first. The very first time you slip a pair of good boots on, I can almost guarantee that you will feel like you have cement blocks on your feet and that you’ll never be able to bend your ankles or knees like I’m telling you to do. Your ankles may even be in an uproar and you may have tears in your eyes. Just muster all your strength and give those nasty boots the deepest knee and ankle bend you can. If you absolutely can’t bend them, then the boot is too much for you and you should ask for the next lower model -- as long as that isn’t the one with the blades bolted on. (If you find that the pair with the blades bolted on is the ONLY pair you can bend, work on your leg strength and shop for boots again in a few months.)
Yikes!
Baby Booties!
On the other hand, if you can bend skating boots as easily as baby booties (this is bad; there should be some resistance), and they feel great (new figure skates never really do), they are probably too soft. Yes, your boots can be too soft. Once upon a time, when skaters spent most of their days doing the ankle-building tracings called figures -- and relatively little time jumping -- soft boots were the norm. Nowadays, virtually all boots, even many of those meant for recreational skaters, are stiffer than Great-Grandma’s – although this does not mean you will never find soft boots in the store. For the serious skater of today, soft boots are useless and may even cause injuries. However, if you want to spend your first couple of months in class in Great-Grandma’s glove-leather, nearly knee-high lace-ups, and the blades are sharpened and the boots fit you closely, and you don’t have issues with your ankles, then it is okay – for a few months. The moment your feet leave the ice for your first bunny hop or waltz jump, however, your Great-Grandma’s need to go back into the attic.
Blades.
I'm not very conversant in the more technical aspects of bladelore. For that kind of information, look at this site: http://vesc.ca/blades.htm. This site gives very good descriptions of how blades are made and what the terms "radius" and "rocker" refer to; however, I'd stop short of blindly accepting the author's opinion that beginners need blades with huge rockers. Personally I believe that most beginners would spend so much time sitting on the ice due to rocker-y blades that they would get frustrated with the sport and take up jogging on dry land instead.
What I will present here are my conclusions based on personal experience, and the advice I've been given through the years.
I've been told that the general rule for adults is to get the best blades you can afford, but do not buy “K-picks” which are for advanced jumpers. The new parabolic blades may be an okay choice, although they, too, are more expensive and there is much argument about whether they are any different than regular blades. The trouble with "the best blade you can afford" is that the cost of some blades will eat up a couple of months' worth of groceries in some households. Add this to the cost of even modestly-priced boots, and it can rob your kids of presents for the holidays.
But there is a happy medium. A safe general rule is to avoid anything that is meant for “recreational” or “beginner.” If there is no designation, assume that the cheapest blades on display are the ones you don’t want. After all, there's a reason they're cheap. Your skills may outgrow these beginner blades in 6 months. How can this happen? Well, I have a limited understanding of blades, but I assume it’s because the picks on "beginner blades" are too dainty (yes, that big awful pick you keep tripping over right now can actually get to be too small once you start to progress), and the materials used in creating the blade are probably not as good.
As an adult skater, you want blades to last far longer than 6 months before they start frustrating you. Three to five years is a good average lifespan for many adults' blades (the more you skate, the shorter the life of the blade), so you can see why it’s not worth buying “beginner” blades: you are not going to be a beginner for three to five years!
Two brands of blades are widely available: Wilson and M-K, which are made in the
Right from the start of their skating careers, many adults prefer the M-K Professional blade, or the Wilson Coronation Ace or Coronation Comet blade. All of these are very similar; there's just a difference in radius between the models. As I said, I still don't entirely understand the concept of radius (your blade dealer will know about this and be able to explain its impact on your skating); I think it has something to do with how big of a circle the blade will draw...never mind. All I know is that I can't skate very well on a blade with an 8' radius (apparently the opposite is true of most skaters). Most Wilson blades -- except for the Coronation Ace with its 7' radius -- have an 8' or greater radius, as do all of the Jackson Ultima blades. All of M-K's blades have a 7' radius, which is why I chose the Professional as my first serious blade; I also tried the Coronation Ace at one point and found it not very different, if at all different, from the Professional. Regardless of that, all three of these blades are good, reliable freestyle blades; even so, beware the K-picks because these models come in an optional K-pick design. None of these blades can be described as "cheap," but they are certainly inexpensive compared to some of the more advanced blade models. However, many adults start with more advanced blades such as M-K Phantom or Wilson Pattern 99, and never leave them. Pattern 99 in particular seems to be very, very popular. I currently have a blade that I have been told is nothing other than a less-expensive version of the Phantom; it's called the M-K Vision. It has larger toe-picks and more of a "bump" at the ball of the foot than the Professionals I previously had. These blades took a bit of getting used to, but now I love them. So again, everyone is different.
In the years since I first wrote this essay, several new blade manufacturers have appeared. I don’t know anything about their products at all. All I can say is, if you really have no idea what you want, I’d stick with the old-standby M-K Professional, or Wilson Coronation Ace or Coronation Comet at this point, or else, if you are in the U.S. or Canada, look into Ultimas. With any of these blades I can almost guarantee happiness for the first few years of skating.
DON’T FILE YOUR PICKS OFF. Yes, I’ve met skaters who have done this. Of course you are tripping over your picks right now; if you’re a beginner, that’s what they’re for. They are also handy emergency brakes, but don’t tell your coach I said so.
The point is, you are going to learn to stay off your picks very soon (HINT: BEND THOSE KNEES AND ANKLES and PRESS DOWN ON YOUR HEEL as you begin your glide). Then you are going to learn skills that require the use of picks. Many jumps require some use of the pick (this is why the first tooth at the top of the pick is sometimes bigger than the others); dabs at the pick are also used in turns, which are used for spinning and jumping (this is why the last tooth on the pick is also sometimes bigger than the others).
Picks are a small but essential part of figure skating. Don’t waste all that money you spent by irreparably damaging your blades for a false sense of security right now.
It is important, and will become more important as you progress, to have your blades sharpened regularly. Some skaters do this every 30 skating hours. I judge the condition of the blades by gently running a thumbnail over the edges. If a small portion of outer nail surface is scraped away, I don’t need a sharpening yet – unless I can feel a dull surface before I feel the bite of a sharp edge. But don’t worry about that. Just time it to “every thirty hours” at first, and be faithful about it.
I’ve known adults who have tried to convince themselves (and others) that they did not need to have their blades sharpened at all, ever. One even told me that blade sharpening ruined the shape of the blades (which it does, eventually) and was a waste of money (which it isn’t). I think it’s significant to note that the “blade experts” who used to hand out this kind of advice to me and others back when I started have long since left the sport. Could it have been because of their blades
?
The fact is that skating is about edges. Speed, fluency and control are attained through the use of edges. “Beautiful skating on edges,” as one famous Russian coach calls it, is attained -- of course -- only with the use of edges. Most importantly to the beginner, one can achieve safety with edges. Smooth stopping is attained with edges (my remark about toe picks being emergency brakes was a joke
). If you feel you’re losing control, go for an edge and glide on it. It will return you to a sense of calm rather than panicking, going for the abrupt halt of the toe pick (or your butt, or worse, your arm or someplace else), and possibly getting hurt.
The point is, if you don’t have nice, sharp blades, you won’t be able to use your edges. Edges are everything. Therefore, sharpening is important.
HAVE YOUR BLADE SHARPENINGS DONE BY A PROFESSIONAL. I can’t stress this enough. You CANNOT do it yourself. A skating blade is a true work of art – and a finicky one. Sharpening a skating blade, with all its subtle surfaces and angles, is a skill that requires years to perfect. Moreover, if your blades are sharpened badly, you can end up badly hurt.
Baby your blades. Wear rubber blade guards when walking around off the ice. (Yes, you will see lots of kids and coaches wandering around without them, but this is risky behavior and can shorten the life of a blade.) You will prolong the life of your blades and sharpenings by using guards and also by drying your blades thoroughly with a towel, or better yet, a chamois, after skating. Most blades rust, so it is essential to get them as dry as possible as fast as possible after skating -- particularly if you live in a humid climate. When thoroughly dry, blades should be stored in cushy blade covers or at the very least wrapped in a soft towel.
Still More: Lace your boots tightly at the ankle, but somewhat less tightly further up than that because very tight laces there will inhibit ankle and knee bending. It’s up to you how tightly you want them laced over the foot; some skaters insist that you shouldn’t lace tightly over the instep and others insist you should. Experiment. Just never leave your laces completely loose because you run the risk of injury. With properly laced boots, you should have a strong sense that your blade is an extension of your foot and you should be aware of everything happening with the blade. There should be no wobbling within the boot.
Invest in gel sleeves or moleskin. Even middle-of-the-line boots can tear the skin on your ankles, and I’ve found that gel sleeves are the only way to prevent this; apparently moleskin works as well, but I have not tried it. Socks will not help, and you don’t want such a silly injury to cut into your enjoyment and keep you off the ice. On the other hand, you can use too many gel sleeves and throw your balance off. Never place gel sleeves on the bottoms of your feet. Only wear one gel sleeve or patch per foot if you can, and never layer a gel sleeve/patch on top of another gel sleeve/patch.
Do not wear heavy socks under your boots. They won’t keep you warm (if you have icicle toes, invest in thermal boot covers), and if the boots are fitted well, you won’t be able to do it, anyway. If you can wear big woolies under your boots, take the boots back. They do not fit correctly. There should be just enough room in your boots for your feet, a thin pair of socks, wafer-thin orthotics if needed, and perhaps gel sleeves or pads. That’s it --and that’s far less than it sounds like. Thick socks can shift around, which can cause potentially nasty control problems even if you have the sensation that your foot is being held motionless in the boot.
As a beginner, you may want to invest in knee pads. This is because you can expect to trip over your picks a bit at first. Always wear gloves for the same reason. If you are really not feeling confident, wearing a helmet is fine. Serious head injuries are rare in skating, but if you feel a risk, address it. (And hey – hockey skaters wear helmets and they usually have nothing in their heads to protect!)
If you think you can get around all of the boot/blade issues by buying hockey skates, you are mistaken. Yes, I’ve seen people, (mainly talented children), do figure skating successfully in hockey skates. No, you will probably not be able to do that. That does not mean you are not talented, it just means that you grew up.