By Mark Ellerby
I think the social isolation of people with mental illnesses experienced as a result of the policy of care in the community magnifies the therapeutic importance of the family immensely, even and especially whilst living in Sheltered Accommodation. I have friends including staff members at the project I live in but being able to ‘go home’ as I call it is still tremendously important. It helps that my parents know what to do in a crisis and learned this from experience. Otherwise it may be that going home to stay overnight (as I do) would not be possible.
It also helps in that a change of scenery is tremendously important. A change is I have heard it said as good as a rest. It is even better - following this line of thought further - that you are able to go on holiday with relatives, at least once or twice a year to break the year up and especially during the long winter months. People who have supportive families are also a lot happier around Christmas time and more so if you have nieces and nephews (I have one of each). Without this contact there may be a need for anti-depressants.
I guess in a way I am very lucky to have all this family input. Years ago they say if any one in the family had a history of mental illness it was never talked about. With the media image of ‘lunatics’ I am sure families still have a hard time coping with the stigma. Carers need carers themselves but may perhaps experience isolation because they feel they mention problems like this to friends. As a result there is a great reliance on health care professionals who are already overworked.
Often too it is only the immediate family that has much direct contact with medical people and social workers and their understanding of the acute nature of mental illness, the ins and outs of hospital, stigma and many other aspects will not be shared by other relatives etc. This can create the odd problem when your parents go on holiday and there is a crisis. I guess the first impulse to ring your family for help but they cannot always be there. Ringing another relative instead can be a bewildering experience for them so sheltered accommodation is a very good answer here in case of emergency.
Another important point is that severe problems with paranoia fuelled by general hostility to mental illness from the community can mean that everyday functions like going shopping are very difficult. Again going with a family member to the supermarket or shopping mall can not only be supportive but also vital. This also gives an experience of normality and to that extent overcomes feelings of social exclusion as well. Many people I know do not have the confidence to do this and in my case family support was needed. It also helps you on the way to greater independence.
The opposite effect is also true – that families have to push the sufferer to go out and do things because it can sometimes be to easy not to confront these problems. You can easily for example avoid going out and get just about anything off the internet. Learned behaviour from bad reactions to going out can lead to a phobia so getting a push to go can in the end increase your confidence. There are no hard and fast rules for when to push and when not to but I think this is an important point. It can just as easily be argued why go out if it makes you ill which again is I think a legitimate issue.
Another large area is family support during visits to doctors and psychiatrists etc. This is I think important because the turnover amongst medical personnel is quite high and they do not have the time to ponder anyone individual case for long nor to fully read the case history. Family will as a result probably know a lot more than the doctors and social workers involved and in my case have often been the only constant element throughout an illness which has varied a lot through fifteen years of problems. As a result for example I rely quite heavily on having someone to assess the trend as compared to the past.
There is also, I think, a professional stereotype that parents worry unduly - especially mothers – and press the panic button at the first sign of trouble. This is a tricky one but can it seems be overcome in the following way. The first thing to do is indeed to call for a doctor at the first sign of trouble and to say why regardless of what the doctor might think. In my case my family have had me sectioned several times but when I got to hospital it became very apparent to the doctors why. From that moment on they paid very close attention to my mother’s opinions and a social worker even remarked “no one knows you like your mother!” Schizophrenia is always taken seriously by doctors and repeating episodes are very common too, so ringing doctors should not be seen as over reacting.
In the end there are probably a myriad of other ways in which families help the patient outside of hospital including in all the ways we have and need to rely on them during normal life. The emotional aspects, feeling wanted, being loved (etc etc) are the most profound and important, loss of this aspect through stigma or whatever just creates a void here and makes the negative experience of the illness worse. Again there are so many potential positives I have been ill for 15 years but never once have had depression. This I think says a lot about the importance of family to mental illness.
Schizophrenia a Personal Experience.
At age 21 life could not be better. I had just graduated from University with a first class degree, had been accepted to study for a doctorate with funding (the academic equivalent of being selected for the Olympic team) and had a research supervisor who was a member of the House of Lords. What could go wrong?
Nothing, or so it seemed. Then it happened: Schizophrenia. It wasn't a sudden shock, more of a gradual onset, although nothing had prepared me for it. Nobody takes you aside at school and says, "Look you might get a mental illness!" There was no information available to allow a self-diagnosis. I had heard of Schizophrenia but thought it was a split or dual personality. It was all the more frightening back then, as I didn't know how to help myself.
For the first few years I stayed at University in Southampton - at the opposite end of the country and away from home and family. I managed to keep my head above water on my course, as the symptoms were not so bad at the start. I kept hearing people talking about my actions, behaviour and thoughts. Eventually I spent more time thinking about this than my work and had to give it up and go home – just in time.
My psychiatrist described my symptoms as particularly severe so they are probably worth recounting. I kept hearing the neighbours banging on the walls trying, (so I thought) to play on my nerves. My response was to run not just out of the house but to get as far away as possible. That meant getting away from everybody. I wandered round the countryside at night trying to avoid towns and villages, from which direction I could still hear the banging noise. I had paranoia and auditory hallucinations all mixed together.
This however was not the end of the matter. I had other kinds of delusions. I thought I was responsible for all kinds of problems: wars, crime, disease etc etc. The worst such symptom was that I had memories of being the reason why everything from TV programmes to the architecture of buildings had the form and appearances they did. It was like wandering around in my own subconscious. I tried umpteen times to commit suicide but was sectioned and taken to hospital.
I was in there for more than a year while `they' the doctors tried to find the right drug. The illness never was a continual thing – I had good periods and bad. Then I was put on Risperidone and some of the delusional symptoms seemed to improve. I still had other problems – most notably strange thoughts and periodic head pains – but I think the doctors must have thought that by then I had gone through the system and come out the other side!
I was left to live independently. That proved very difficult. The stigma of mental illness made me a virtual recluse. You can't go down the pub and face the inevitable question what do you do and reply your schizophrenic. On my own the presence of the voices seemed to be magnified and there was little to help the depression this created. The answer was to live in sheltered accommodation -and as with my stay in hospital this improved things further.
What I have learned about having such an illness is that one of the best things which can be done is to simply talk to the patient. I guess this can act as a distraction from dwelling on your problems. Living together in sheltered housing aims to provide such a context. Some kind of activity is also necessary but this can be a double edged sword – work can be stressful but then doing nothing can be the same so it is often necessary to balance the two. Variety in terms of people and activity is also necessary.
The biggest help in my case seems at present to be the drug clozapine. My mental health has been greatly improved since the very first time I was prescribed it. That was two years ago! I still have some symptoms and side effects but I am a thousand times better than I was. I have started to research and write again. This time about mental health. To date I have had much published.
Hope and Hopelessness.
Giving up hope is a slow process and for was concurrent with the gradual intrusion of schizophrenia into my life. At 22 I was working in a bar on nights, and researching politics. I wanted to be an academic. Slowly however my concentration and studying was being overtaken by voices and paranoid thoughts. This distracted me at first and I became less effective. My first reaction was deny it was happening but then I began to experience a growing sense of fear and paranoia. I gave up my bar job but still tried to tell myself that I would succeed no matter what. The more we relinquish social contacts like jobs and courses the more we resort to blind instinctual faith in ourselves and the more we try to persuade ourselves that it is not really happening.
But this blind faith is the essence of hope and what drives a person to survive schizophrenia. Hopelessness really comes about for me when we give up on our ambitions. I have only experienced this once in 15 years of illness. I threw away my theses that I had worked on for 5 years. Things (life) can seem that it is coming to an end. The subconscious drive to win means we never really give up though. And then all of a sudden everything comes right. Nor is it that if we loose our dreams that new things come to replace them. We do not loose sense of direction it was just that I was no longer conscious of it. I have now gone back to university but no longer aspire to it. On the other hand I no longer need to hope for a cure (though of course this would be welcome).
Feelings of hopelessness can be accentuated by material deprivation – this serves to reinforce the impression that nothing is going right. We begin to represent everything as negative but also to deny that it is all really happening. Faced with overwhelming problems we begin to exist in a kind of state of limbo or nothingness. A complex set of influences come into play which reinforces this picture including isolation, poverty, loss of hope and motivation as well as the symptoms of schizophrenia. We are unable to help ourselves. Thankfully this becomes noticeable to everyone and hospital comes to the rescue. From then on we can begin to gain some perspective or insight into these problems, we begin to reconnect with reality.
Becoming part of the world again can take a considerable length of time. How do we explain a period in hospital - it leaves a major gap on your CV. So once again we have to confront the possibility that we may not achieve our goals in life. Another factor here is that once we have seen the revolving door phenomenon we realise there are a more or less stable number of people for whom the illness is an ongoing thing. Then we realise in turn that you are going to become part of that group. That thought looms large in one consciousness and ones dreams seem even more distant and unattainable. So much for being the ‘loony bin’ in this respect. Giving up hope can actually imply a sense of contentment with one change of circumstance.
How does this occur? One way is that we end up finding new interests. This can be something really simple like walking. I do not mean for long distances either. It is surprising how we find new things in the immediate environment in which we are forced to live. It is a sign of adaptability which is very encouraging though learning to adapt can take quite some time. In my old life I used to go every where by car, even to the corner shop. I could not imagine life without it, now I cannot imagine life with a car! What was a necessity for me now just seems a luxury. The development of new and therapeutic activities is instrumental in establishing a more positive outlook to life. With the right support life is no longer limbo but quite palatable – we are not totally focused on what we have lost or what might have been.
This in many ways is the key point. In my case I was always wondering whether my academic arguments were correct. This can really wound your pride - if it turns out to be the case - and for me I just had to trust my instincts until I was well enough to go back to university and finish the research. A failed ambition can be very damaging to the ego just as an unfulfilled ambition can make you bitter. Either way these feelings can be a spur to action and for me made me never give up. Even though I threw away my research I have gone back and am well on the way to completing it. I guess there is a vital lesson here even when you give up you never totally give up. It is worth reflecting on the reasons for this.
Motivation as I have said is subconscious to the point that whatever seems apparently hopeless is not lost. You have just got to go with your instinctual feelings about ambition. You will always in some small part of your mind never give up and even if you waste years on your doubts it will come right eventually. Even when the cause of the doubt is the shattering impact of schizophrenia and the like on your confidence. Support systems are a major help in this respect and once some things in your life begin to improve as does your whole outlook eventually. Even if you never recover your goals are not lost it may be just a matter of adapting and adjusting what counts for you as achievement. It is just as important to me now to write about mental health as it was a decade ago to writing about politics.
I do not know if I have now recovered from schizophrenia or not! I still have periodic bouts of delusional fear but most of the time I feel really quite normal. This prospect for me has come as quite a shock. I have become so familiar with the system and have met so many people with ‘life long’ problems that you inevitably end up classifying yourself among them. Having improved considerably from my past essays on
I guess the lesson here is that every cloud has a silver lining ‘There is always hope.’
so keep hoping.
Mark Ellerby
Durham