Just so everyone knows I am going to send (to those who said they want it) "Constructive Criticism." We will only send it to those we think needed to hear it. We are sending it to e-mails because we respect that your same videos are entered into other award sites and we don't want to influence the outcome of your awards. If you don't recieve an e-mail about it then we didn't think you needed it.  Please know that it doesn't mean that we didn't like it, its just maybe some ways to improve on your vidding. We are not perfect ourselves at vidding but we do see alot of things that could help maybe some that are still learning like us.

 

One more thing I need to say is I wont be reviewing every video after this. It takes to much time for me because I like to watch each video a few times to know exactly what I want to say. I am so sorry it took so long to type this out. From now on I will only review the videos who won judges choice awards. However, if you feel that maybe you didn't win an award for certain categories and want to know what we thought, feel free to ask me to review it and I will do my best.

 

Round 4 Reviews

By: YCATS

 

Leah - Harry Osborn: Papercut:

Leah I love this song and I think it is perfect for Harry and his Dad. You match the lyrics so nicely but at the same time you always are very creative using different effects and colors. This is one of my favorites you have done. 00:06 - 00:10 is so cool at the begining! It drew me in from start to finish. "Its like I'm paranoid looking over my back" is just so cool how you used it with every scene choice. 01:53 - 02:05 is nicely done how you show Harry's Dad's face and all the thoughts of Harry.

 

 

Leah - Anakin's Its Never Too Late (AU):

Another great song choice. Three Days Grace is awesome....But guess what? Your video is just as awesome! I really like how you had the ghost motion with a grey tint on those parts of the song such as 00:41-00:42 with the music. I like how not only is this story about Anakin and Padme but Obi as well. I really like how towards the end Padme is like pleading with him but at first he is like in a daze 02:13 - 02:21 and it replays padme falling untill he snaps out of it. Still as stubburn as he is, he fights Obi-wan. Obi pleads with Anakin as well and then Anakin at the end survives and goes to Padme, I LOVE THAT! Great story and happy ending. I like how you made it as if he actually went there. Nice colors and effects as always. I also like how you zoom into certain parts.

 

JediCaro - Star Wars: "I just want you to know":

Great use of song for this video, it made me cry! I like the hazy sepia memories somewhat of a glow. Good portrayal to show Anakin/Vader's soft side. What I find so touching is that you showed how despite Vader feeling like he doesn't want the world to know him, he still wants to know Luke. I love 03:01-03:18 going from color back to sepia, showing how real memories can be at times. Really nice colors and I think you did a wonderful job flowing the scenes with the music.

Ladykate - Shattered-Lizzie Bennet:

This video is beautifully put together. I always like when memories are identified by some way (colors, blur, glow ect.) I really like that in your video. We can see the hopefullness Lizzie has yet the sadness she feels. I like 02:15-02:27 nice how you have Darcy talk with the low part of the song and then as Lizzie wakes the song starts getting higher again. I like the split screen scenes. Great blending and fading.

Ladykate - One Day

Really nice video for Thornten & Margaret! I like the song choice with the video. 0:30-0:36 I liked how you had the picture turn grey. As always throughout the video I enjoy the color and tone or glow that was used. What I really enjoyed is that this video really puts out there how much he cares for Margaret, but in the end there is still that question if they end up together. Really nicely done!!

 

HeathDances - Memories

WOW Heather! This is so beautiful and tragic at the same time. I love this AU so much! First off its nice how you show the feelings John would have if he was mourning the death Margaret. I really love the glow effects used on her. Its so sad and haunting. The editing and timing is really wonderful. The song choice was excellent and great scene choices. 2:31-2:36 is really nicely blended together! You did a masterpiece again Heather!

 

HeathDances - Finally

This is so cute! This song is great for Elizabeth's POV. I like the part that said "cinderella theme, crazy as it seems" along with Elizabeth in her beautiful dress. Again there is nice timing with the simple fade to black and good choice of scenes. I like the vignette you used in this video. 3:22-3:47 is really nice how you used the light moviing down and then in just crossfades into a close up of Lizzy with Mr Darcy blended in there walking to her. Very nice as usual and we loved it!

 

The Duchez - Mr. Darcy's Twisted

I Really love this video so much! It is different then other P&P vids because of the song choice. It fits Darcy so well because he probably would feel very twisted over Elizabeth. I like the timing in the video. Transitions were nice and I aprreciate how you left the rap part in, most vidders would have taken that out. Great scene choices and beautiful ending.

 

The Duchez - Let It Whip

This is another great unique song choice. What I love most of all is all the action! It was nice to give awards for A Knights Tale with Heath Ledger in them. We really like how the scenes go so well with the song. We especially like the parts that say "I sense something devine in you...." and it builds up in the music with the colors changing. Really nice transitions that didn't distract from the greatness of the video! Excellent job!

 

ShannypantsMoviez - Obidala- A New Day Has Come

Nice concept for this video. I like the glows showing how much Obi-wan meant to Padme. I like the begining alot and I feel that it showed the most potential for this video. We could see how Padme yearned to be with Obi-wan. In the end even though she died it was nice how you showed Luke to be living on for her.

 

ShannypantsMoviez - Star Wars- Its all Coming Back to me now

It was cute how you showed that even after Anakin hurt padme so much that she still remembered everything about them she tried to forget so many times. Everytime he touches her and holds her...she remembers their love. She even remembers them when they first met. I know Sony Vegas is not an easy program to use so I give you props for your hard work.

 

Val - A Walk to Remember - The Way I am

This video is so sweet! The minute we saw it we fell in love with it. You were so creative making this in the fact that the lyrics are so different then any other song choice for Landon & Jamie. I like the parts that change from color to black and white. I also really like the pictures at the begining and ending. I have to admit i have never heard this song but from the moment I saw your video you made me fall in love with it. Thanks for the wonderful video Val!

Val - Pride & Prejudice AU - Different Impressions

Val we really love how you put this together. It was like a mini movie. So different though as if we watched a different film from the original. You made it work so well with this scenes. In part 2 especially we like 2:54-3:30 it really looks as if Mr. Bingley proposed to Elizabeth. I love how this video flows and doesn't need anything fancy. I always enjoy that about your videos! You picked great music to go along with the video and feelings of the characters. Great Job VAL!

 

SmokeyFizz/GoneVidder - February Song

This is so creative and beautiful but still so sad! 0:33-0:51 is stunning. The glow used through the video we liked alot! This fits Obi-wan's POV so well. We really like the colors used in this video. 3:17-3:44 was really cool with the overlay and scenes flowing through the backround. Topping everything else was when you showed Luke in there. I really felt how Vader was in a way "found" after being lost. 4:50 to the end is so amazing in that Anakin finally (as Vader) opened his eyes and changed. This was so sweet and different I really love the unique factor in this video.

 

 

SmokeyFizz - Circles

This is such an amazing video that from the start it draws you in. I love the effects used in this you girls!! at about 0:45 you have Padme disappear, AMAZING! I had to rewind it so many times and still am in awe of that. You did it again later in the video at about 0:58-0:59 and that just really drew me to love and appreciate all the hard work you put into this. Great timing with the switching of scenes and this cool effect (not sure what its called) but its like a swipe of a blur. 1:03-1:08 is so awesome and I love the way you showed Padme's true beauty even after she died. Another this about this masterpiece is how you can see how Anakin really meant for something good to happen through his fall to the darkness. He was "running in circles" but only to save Padme his love. Again like I said this video is just so amazing and I love it.

 

Kerry - Good Enough

I love this video Kerry! It is a perfect song choice for them. Through all the stress and anger they had they really did feel this way inside towards each other. 1:32-1:34 is cool with the timing and feel of the video. The quote at the start is really nice to show the feeling they had for each other went far beyond the empty talk they started with. Beautiful video and I must say I am a fan of your videos for sure!

 

Kerry - Pride and Prejudice - Iris

Nice flow of this video with the timing of the song. Love the part 2:21-2:42 with the flashing effects. Nice glow effect through the video. 2:43-2:53 is really cool with the overlays, Elizabeth walking and the scenes ontop of it. The lyrics fit Elizabeth & Darcy so well. It like at the end you have them walking in the field with "I just want you to know who I am." It makes sense to me to because other people didn't understand (like his Aunt) his love for such a common girl. Great Video!

 

 

 

starwarschick16 (Lauren) - Anakin's "So Far Away"

This is a very nice portrayal of the way Anakin felt in ep3. Of course you know I like this song alot because I made a video for this fandom and song too! I like the fact you showed how far away Anakin really is. Anyone listening to this song would most likely agree its written for Anakin.

 

 

starwarschick16 - Keep Holding On

This is probably my favorite video you have made Lauren. I think its so sweet how you put it together. Padme was always there for Anakin from the start. Good choice of clips for the video! Nice addition with Luke at the end. I like how Anakin could have what he wanted finally after everything that happened.

 

 

starwarschick16 (other vid not submitted i promised to judge) - over my head

This is so creative Lauren! It fits Padme's desciption of "Paulo" so well. I like the unique factor of this so much! I think this is your most well edited video yet. It showed how through everything Frodo still thinks of Padme all the time and visa versa. Its like he sees Padme in his mind and he aches knowing he is not with her. This is such sweet sadness. I can tell you put alot of effort in this and keep up the good work! Even though I don't care for The Lord of the Rings you made me fall in love with this idea and video. GREAT JOB!

 

 

Episodeskywalker/Cody137 - Falling Inside the Black

OMG What can I say but I am in love with this video. Its got a darkness to it but so good in so many ways. I can tell you how much I LOVE TIMING IN A VIDEO, however I don't like when people overdue the timing. This video you both did was just perfect. I loved it I have watched it so many times. I think it brings Anakin's POV out in such a awesome way. You feel the torture he must have has with the dreams of Padme dying. The glow, the colors, the grey and black effect are just used in such an effective way. 2:10-2:20 is my favorite part! Its so dark showing how he fell. Also I like the end showing him become Vader "falling inside the black." Just one of my favorite videos ever!

 

 

Sara - All good Things

Never thought of using this song to Star Wars but it really fits Ani & Padme. It so sad how everything came to an end. Really tragic how Padme had to die at the end. I think you put the scenes of Anakin * Padme at the end to show that those were the "Good times" that so sadly came to an end.

 

 

BlueSalad - I'm Still Here

I like this video. I am sorry it didn't get into a certain category for an award becuase it so cool. I haven't seen a video like this one till yours. I like how different the guys are but they all fit into the song lyrics.

 

BlueSalad - Home

This is really cool for P&P. Again this is unique because it is something different but it still fits. Elizabeth is where the home is for Darcy and same the other way around. They may not have known it at first but they find it in the end. I like the famous field scene at the end for their going home. Nice job with the sepia tone scenes.

 

 

Elle - "The Rise and Fall of Superman"

I like the action in this video. It shows how you don't need flashy effects to make a great video. I like the voices in the backround. The music is really cool. Its like watching an action packed trailer. You put all the different supermans together and it worked very well. I like how you put the "Lois & Clark" one in there. I loved that show. I was really impressed with this one. It really showed the "Rise & Fall" superman has had. Great Work!

 

 

Elle - The Lois & Clark Chronicles; Over It

I don't really care for Katherine McPhee but nevertheless, I still thought you did a good job on this. Good work with the scenes for the lyrics. I can tell you had the video put well together in your mind before actually making it. Its always good when we know what we want before making it. So I still thought this was pretty good.

 

Neelma - It Could Be You

Sorry to say I didn't really like this song. It made it hard for us to enjoy the video. But still we liked how you showed how Magaret thinks about Thornton always. Great use of the song through the video such as 1:19 "touch you now baby" that was really sweet. What a happy ending too! Good job!

 

 

Melissa - Need you tonight

WOW what a great video this is. Some of my favorite things: Uniqueness, Timing, Comedy, Suspence and of course Johnny Depp. I really like this video. Everytime I hear this song I think of your video. Mort really fits this song so well in a stalker sort of way. I love the parts where he looks like he says the lyrics. Amazing use of song. I like the part 0:50-0:59 with him saying "Your one of a kind" Brilliant!!! 2 thumbs way way up!

 

Olivia - About You Now

This is a fun cute video. I think it fits them so well. Nice use of song and alot of action. Pretty simple with good timing as well.

1:14-1:25 is really good with the timing. I was really impressed how well you put the scenes and music together. Good Job and hope to see more from you.

 

Maliang - Love and Desire

This is really cute and different. It was kind of funny but really sweet. Good use of song. It was nice to have something different entered. I like the dancing scene in there with the music. Keep up the vid making and I would love more videos with this Fandom.

 

Maliang - Knight's tale Trailer

This was really good with good action. The only bad part is I couldn't read the subtitles. Pretty good timing and the music was good with the trailer. Nice Job!