Layout:
Your layout is quite lovely, with everything in plain view and all, but because of the advertisement column to the right side of the screen, I have to scroll over to see all of the information in the main display. I don't suppose the ads can be moved, but that does take away a few points since they're a little distracting. Other than those, though, the layout is very professional looking. Also, I could not get the "Tolkien" font to work. I downloaded it, but you site did not change. You might consider picking a font that looks old-english but does not require downloading.
3/5

Color Choice:
Your color choice is exquisite! They work together well, are pleasing to the eye, and don't blend into the background.
5/5

Language:
Your language is very proper and easily understood.
5/5

Function:
You certainly have a lot of links, yet they all seem to be working properly. You may want to see about spacing out the buttons, but this is merely a visual preferance of mine, so don't worry. Also, you may want to have the sites open in new windows, but again, merely a preference.
10/10

Navigation:
Your navigation bar is very much to the point, which is always good, and your gallery set up is very nice.
10/10

Information:
Not to much in the way of learning... I see mostly galleries and graphics with a few snippets, and of course the book summaries, but that's about it. There are, however, the things in the downloads section, but as far as I can tell, neither the dictionary, nor the book collection downloads were written by you, so...
4/10

Media:
You have the basic icons, banners, and backgrounds, but also a few videos and a cursor package.
5/5

Graphics:
Your graphics are beautiful, especially the banners. Nice work!
5/5

Interactivity:
Not really that much interactivity. There's a tagboard and banner requests, but you might want to think about adding a forum; I think you'd be very successful.
6/10

Atmosphere:
Nice atmosphere; everyone seems very friendly.
10/10

Dedication:
As far as I can tell, you're very dedicated. There's updates almost every day, and there are a lot of graphics, which take time to make.
10/10

Creativity:
You do have the fan art, as well as your graphics and other downloads, but I'd like to see more. Maybe you should think of adding a fanfiction section eventualy.
3/5

Originality:
The material on this site all seems to be made by you, or attributed to the rightful owner if it isn't.
5/5

Size:
You've seemed to use quite a bit of space, but I suggest adding a few more pages with more things to do.
4/5

Total:85/100

To Do:
-See about moving the ad bar.
-Add more pages with things such as forums, games, or fanfiction.
-Add biographies or something to bring up 'information' points.