"The Roundtable Discussion"

Brought to you by standAPARTfitness.com!

"What Fitness Trend is Currently Helping/Hurting the Industry?"

Roundtable #11

"Years ago, the stability ball was the hot trend in the fitness field...one year ago it was the kettlebell (and kinda still is). What current 'trend' do you see in the fitness field today and is it helping or hurting the field?"
 
 
Rick Karboviak:
"I've mainly seen a trend of pedometers coming & going, but what has caught my eye lately is the BioTrainer metabolic counter.  I've used this device in my boot camp & athlete speed training sessions, to help me determine metabolic costs of the activities they do.  For instance, while on a 20 minute, high intensity interval run I had my boot campers do, one client burned over 400 calories in that workout.  He was really excited to read that at the end, and he knew just how hard he had worked & how much energy he spent.

The kettlebell seems to be a 'fad' in some eyes, but I don't think it will just up & die, not in this day & age, where there seems to be a reawakening, or new dawn, of the physical culture movement.  There's more of a 'natural' feel with health & fitness being pushed, and to me, kettlebell training helps your body move better naturally.  Its one of the reasons I've chosen to focus a lot of my business on such an item.  Its the symbolic feature of my boot camps, and cornerstone of my athlete training programs.  I've felt its effectiveness and it still amazes me somedays how I can workout with something so small and it benefits me so well. I think the BioTrainers & Kettlebells are advancing the field.  Both are making an impact for accountability purposes (BioTrainer) and simplicity in exercise function & duration (kettlebells).  I've had boot campers lose more weight with 2.5 hours a week of workouts with kettlebells & jump ropes (30min, 5x/week) than 4, 2 hour workout days a week on treadmills, cross-trainers, and weight machines. That to me, is simplifying the fitness confusion that's out there, and if any fad can do that, they will stick around for a long, long time.


Chaney Weiner:

"Trends come and trends go, always have and always will. In the fitness field every time there is a new trend everyone jumps on it until some other comes around and in the end it always goes back to basics. What are the basics…the right tool for the right job. This is the BIG problem with trainers who feel they have to come up with a gadget or use the latest “bandwagon” trend out there to impress their people rather than provide superior service through their skills as a fitness professional. Where trends hurt the fitness industry is when people try and PUSH that trend as their specialty which they may have just learned recently. They try and use that as their main selling point in their services by trying to get people to believe that the trend(SB, KB, etc) is THE tool to use to get clients results. While this type of stuff will always be there and new trends come and go, one thing will always remain…..there is NO substitute for knowing when to use the right tool for the right job and that right there will benefit clients more than any fitness trend ever will."

 Anthony Renna:

"One thing I am seeing more of is trainers substituting the training techniques of  bodybuilders and replacing them with the techniques of Strength and Conditioning coaches when working with their general population clients.  I work for a "big chain" and we have had Mike Boyle, Lee Taft, Gray Cook and others come for lectures and seminars and it has made a tremendous impact on the level of training at our gym. 
Clients are sticking with training longer because they are a) becoming better movers b) getting less injuries outside of the gym in their activities of daily living c) becoming better at the recreational sports they play and d) still seeing the fat loss results that they also desire.
It can only help the field, because if we want to advance and get the respect we deserve, we have to move focus from short term aesthetic goals to long term fitness goals."
 
Roger White:
 
"By far the hottest trend is youth athletic training.  More and more average joes are reading a few books to make a few bucks.  Youth training is at least $4 billion and is on the rise in a hurry.  With $1.8 billion in health care costs to treat injuries, look for this number to rise due to the lack of qualified professionals who understand youth growth, development, and training.  Too many coaches train youth athletes like college and pro athletes.  The needs and demands are not similar and certain repetitive activities may end up resulting in the child being Me Joe Athlete at age 15 and Mr Cripple at age 35."
 
Rob Pilger:
 
First of all I will quote what the late Dr. Mell Siff said about exercises.. " There is no such thing as a bad exercise, just a bad way of performing them" I would add, is the person qualified to do it.. Is their preparedness up to par.
 
Sandbag training, keg, gladiator training(strongman type lifts) have allot of attention now.
 
Do I think there bad, no. Are they that effective, yes. I grew up on a farm for 10 years when I was a very young kid. Bailing hay, carrying 5 gallon buckets of grain, and water, one half empty, one three quarters full. Using a pitch fork cleaning out calf hutches with the pitch fork loaded with calf Dun. Carrying bags of feed of the truck..etc..etc..
 
How is that for unstable training? This has been around forever. Same type of training as you see now with kegs, sandbags, etc..
 
The strong farm boy comes to mind. They, we, are strong for a reason.. I really think that farm work set up my body to handle lots of volume, as I can. I have not been injured in training. I'm 30 yrs young.. I lift very heavy weights. I feel, I have built a solid base of core stabilization through the years from that work.. Also added with what I continue to learn today and add.
  
No fad, it's been here for awhile.. It's been working.. It is not the end all and be all like some think though. It has it's place, and it will continue too.
 
Vince Burke:

"The word "functional" from what I can remember has a Physical Therapy Rehabilitation heritage. Years ago, when I saw someone in the clinic it was all about measuring the range of motion and strength like in sport training--a bench press and a sit and reach test--and never to apply those results to function. At times it may have been an insurance company, a medical doctor or a coach who was only interested in numbers and never cared about function. However, over the last decade or so this has changed and the numbers matter much less than the "function". How does one function in the home after a total hip operation? And how does an athlete function on the field or court? Which all appear to be more important than any given number.

 

In the past in rehab for instance, a person may have been discharged if strength was a 5/5 but a muscle grade number does not really matter, what matters is how she is functioning in her "playing environment” such as home, kitchen and bathroom. If one can’t function in those areas they will not be discharged. As for the athlete, I see it the same way. It is not always about how much you lift or how big your biceps are, but how your body functions to overcome the "bodily functions" of another athlete and the health of the functioning body.

 

Functional training and maintaining function of the bodily systems is truly the future in my opinion. In the years to come it will only get better as we become more creative in simulating sports with training theracises of the game and more scientific of the energy systems needed to perform, and mostly how to recover and nutritionalize the breaking down body. Also, functional training is about learning how to keep your body functioning healthy, enhancing the entire function of the body and all of it systems with control, efficiency, productivity, and safety.

 

In my opinion, this can be achieved with several tools. I feel we will see more Free Motion Machines, Body Weight, Bands and Ball training than ever before. Firstly, they are fun, easy, healthy, functional (mult-itask demanding and multi-dimensional), cost effective and appropriate for all athletes and for anyone who wants to improve their overall “good health function”. All of these tools don’t “fix” the body like many machines such as Cybex or Hammer Strength.  Aside from these tools becoming more popular because they allow gross compounding movements, they place healthy demands on the body (if executed properly). Also functional training is being driven by the science that has done a great job in both research and education on “HOW TO” functional train. Another force is the fitness industry advertisement terminology. I have seen us train our athletes advertising and using both the "body building" way…16 sets of static biceps curls, three times a week and the   ”power lifting" way…supine bench press, two days a week and every other week  one day of “negatives” to the present “functional training” way which is more of a "multi-task/multi-dimensional”  training way  placing more demands on all energy, nervous and musculoskeletal  systems. These tools get us out of the “fixed positions” and into  more “athletic positions” ;  more compounding integrated movements that focus on both fine and gross motor movement patterns.

 

 

John Izzo:

"I see the latest trend in fitness is group training or bootcamps. I think they can be effecient as far as training a group of people in an hour. I think they are great for building support, comardarie, and teams for others to achieve similar fitness goals. However, with the rise in bootcamps, especially in the summer months, I feel that they tend to draw away from individual attention towards the client. Well, I understand they are designed this way, but I am not in favor of "simply kicking your client's ass". I don't favor trainers acting as drill sargents and yelling at 250 lb sedentary clients and not recognizing the physiolgical effects this type of training can create. Injuries can occur through improper instruction...and let's face it, when you train 4-8 people, its hard to keep your eye on everyone--let alone give proper cvues and make sure they are followed through. It' sno wonder that every local news story I see on bootcamps by personal trainers, I alwasy notice in the footage the sloppy push-up form and the sloppy planks."


 

Matt Attanasio:

The trend that I see in our industry that can be a both positive or a negative is exercise videos.  How many are there? Thousands upon thousands.  Why?  Because we have a population of individuals in our country who want the next greatest exercise routine that will get “results.”  These videos are put out by so called “experts” in our field.  The positive is that it may get more people moving there bodies.  The negative is that not one routine fits everybody.   Many times the info on the dvd is outdated or poor technique is demonstrated.  Also the “expert” may not be as qualified, and I’m sure we all have seen videos that wouldn’t qualify as quality information.  Don’t get me wrong.  I’m all for making money.  Especially if you have knowledge and can transfer that knowledge to people in our industry and the everyday world.
 Another positive I see is that one can get their training ideas out to the “world” and provoke new thoughts and theories. This can be profitable and educational, however, our industry is not regulated and anything can get on the market and be sold.  What we can do as qualified trainers is offer advice to these individuals out there who are buying them and hopefully they will take our advice.
 Also, we, as health care professionals and performance coaches should be aware of the latest training videos put out by our industry for our industry.  This industry that we all are in seems to be crying out for new ideas on a daily to weekly basis.  That’s why everybody is putting out a video/dvd.  Where there is a demand, then someone will take advantage of that and hopefully many of the rookies in our industry don’t get poor information in their heads about training and coaching techniques.  The words used like “Secrets” and “Do not miss out,” as well as “Ultimate” can be overdone at times as marketing phrases.  This can ultimately be costly, not only to the trainer, but, more specifically to the client who can get hurt because of these dvd’s/videos and the trainer who may inappropriately apply them.
 

Terms of Service

THE VIEWS EXPRESSED IN “THE ROUNDTABLE” DO NOT NECESSARILY REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF STANDAPARTFITNESS.COM AND MAY BE INTERPRETED IN ANY WAY BY THE READER. ALL STATEMENTS AND CONTENT PROVIDED BY THE CONTRIBUTORS DOES NOT REPRESENT FACTUAL DATA OR VIEWS OF A MAJORITY. THEY ARE ENTIRELY OPINONS AND RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED BY SUCH AUTHORS FOR YOUR READING PLEASURE.

 The material contained in this website, its products, programs, articles, text, messages, newsletters, postings, and photos is provided for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended to be or replace medical advice. Neither standAPARTfitness.com, nor its authors, administrators, affiliates, members, or associates assume any liability for the information contained herein. The information contained in standAPARTfitness.com or its products should not be used to diagnose, treat, or cure any illness, disease, metabolic disorder, or health ailment. Participants, contributors, members, readers, visitors of standAPARTfitness.com should consult a licensed medical physician or health care provided for any aforementioned conditions. Use of the programs, products, advice, and information contained in this website or its affiliated products, links, associates is at the sole choice and risk of the reader and visitor.

 

Without limiting the rights under the copyright reserved above, no part of this publication and/or website (including the title standAPARTfitness.com or its logo) may be reproduced, stored, or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise), without the prior written consent of the author. Use of the websites name, title, logo, products, or publications without prior written consent is illegal and punishable by law.

Create a free website at Webs.com