Catholics and Miscarriage

Your Logo Here

 

 

Site Navigation    



 
 
 

Miscarriage : understanding your loss from a catholic perspective.


God,
We remember all babies who have died as a result of miscarriage. We remember all mothers and fathers whose hearts are aching and arms empty, who never had a chance to love or hold their babies. We ask God’s healing to fill the void and emptiness that has been left.
Amen

For babies lost through miscarriage, there is often no public mourning, no funeral or flowers, no gathering of friends. If you have lost a baby through miscarriage you may feel a very deep loss which few others seem to understand. Bereavement is a lonely experience. It is unique, and it is sometimes very private. It is often difficult to share your grief with another person, however close that person is. Often other people don’t know how to offer comfort. Sometimes the wrong things are said. Well-meant words can hurt; observations intended to help can sound glib and superficial. Close family and friends may be shocked and sad, but grateful that the mother’s life is not in danger. Medical staff may tell you cheerfully, “Don’t worry, you’ve got plenty of time to try again.” But to you and your partner, your loss may be devastating. Your baby is gone, and nothing can change this fact or bring your baby back.

The Christian faith places a high value on the unborn. The Bible teaches that human beings are made in God’s image (Genesis 9:3-6). The detailed description of foetal life as portrayed in Psalms 139, offer a clear picture of God’s concern for and intimate involvement with human beings from before conception. The Catholic faith upholds that life begins at conception, when the egg and sperm unite and the full genetic potential is in place. The Catholic faith also teaches that life should be defended from conception. This means acknowledging that at conception a new life is truly present. Therefore, if you are a Christian who has been brought up with these beliefs, from the moment you discovered that you and your partner were expecting a baby, you will have loved that new life in the womb. You may have developed a relationship with it. You may have read books about its development. You may have known its size and shape. To you it may have been a real miniature person, not a lump of tissue. To you it may have been another human being growing inside his or her mother’s womb. From very early on in the pregnancy, you may have been looking forward to being this baby’s parent. You may have felt ready to welcome him or her into your life and cherish it with the unconditional love that only a parent can give. Losing your baby through miscarriage means that your child’s life ended just as it was beginning and all your hopes and dreams for the near future are shattered.

After your miscarriage, you may have received sympathy from family and friends. You may have been told to rest for a week or two. Friends may have ran errands for you. Soon you may have felt physically strong and looked well. But inside you may still be in a state of frozen grief and mourning. You have lost your baby, yet you may not have received any public recognition of your bereavement, for your loss is not seen by all as a baby who has died, but as an embryo or foetus that didn’t quite make it. When you are grieving, you need time. You can’t rush through bereavement and back to ‘normal life’, for in one sense your life will never be normal again. Losing a baby through miscarriage is not something you ‘get over’ in the way that you recover from the flu. Instead the loss becomes part of you. You gradually learn to live with the memories, happy and sad, of the time you were expecting your baby. Losing a baby is a shock to your entire body, and grief will affect you physically, emotionally and spiritually. The cascading emotions you feel are normal reactions to loss : shock, disbelief, sadness, anger, protest, guilt, fear, resentfulness and jealousy. You may feel some or all of these emotions. You may experience several of these emotions at once, or they may arise at different times. The depth of your grief shows the strength of your love for your lost child, and it is normal to feel as though you need help with this grief. It is also normal to feel as though you need empathy and understanding and a need to know there are those who love and care.


FINDING COMFORT AND HEALING THROUGH PRAYER

At times, you may find that prayer and reflection help you through your time of loss. Still too in shock to share your feelings with other people, you may feel that you can talk freely to God.

You may feel that your time of prayer is like a memorial service, sharing with God all the things about expecting a baby that you miss the most. For example, in your prayer, you may relive the joy and elation that you experienced when you discovered that you were going to become a parent, the excitement that you felt when choosing a name for your baby, the thrill of planning for your baby’s arrival and the wonder of your baby’s presence bringing about changes to its mother’s body or moving inside her.

You may find comfort in the words of the Old Testament : “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you” (Jeremiah 1:5). This reminds us of God’s providential plan for everyone, including your miscarried baby, who was a precious creation despite his or her brief life. You may find comfort in believing that you now have an angel in heaven. You may be able to cry and pour out your sorrow to God, and then feel at peace. You may feel that you are able to leave your unborn baby in a love and care even greater than your own.

As times goes by, you may wish to thank God for your identity as a parent, even if you lost your baby though an early miscarriage. As a mother, you conceived and loved this child and carried him or her inside your body. As a woman who has lost her baby, you are still a mother, as what may be missing from the future does not cancel out what you have been through in the past. Likewise, fatherhood is about raising, supporting and loving a child. You may have been fully prepared to do just that but tragic circumstances occurred and so preventing you from getting the chance. As a man who has lost his baby through miscarriage, you are still a father to this child because you stood willingly to do all that a father does.

In time, you may feel comforted seeing that the world has become a better place because of your baby. You may feel that your baby’s life and death had a positive effect on someone else. You and your partner may have strengthened your relationship even further. You may have connected more deeply with your faith. Your friends and family may have drawn closer to you during your crisis. You may discover your own wisdom or personal strength, especially if you use the experience to help someone else or to make positive life changes.


ANGRY WITH GOD

At other times, you may feel too angry to pray. You may feel angry that God did not answer your prayers for a healthy pregnancy and the safe delivery of your much wanted and loved baby. You may believe that God could have done so, but for some unfathomable reason chose not to. The idea of having an angel in heaven may not comfort you or your partner who are grieving the loss of your cherished baby. These well-intended comments offered by caring friends and relatives may sound shallow and inconsequential.

Outrage at the very existence of suffering has been an important factor in the modern debate with atheism : with some justification, the proportion of evil and suffering in the world has come to be regarded as the most telling argument against the very existence of an all-loving Creator. An atheist may ask how you can believe in a heavenly father or a heavenly mother, when it appears that this God cares so much less than an earthly father or mother. You may feel that as a parent, you had done everything within your power to try and protect your unborn baby, while God just seemed to ignore all your pleas for help.

When you discovered that you were going to be a parent, you may have prayed to thank God for this precious gift of new life. The birth of a first baby is for most couples the biggest event of their lives so far. Parenthood is a wonderful privilege because it allows you to participate fully in the earthly creation of another person. A couple experiencing the miracle of pregnancy and birth may be brought closer to acknowledging God than ever before. Following a pregnancy loss, you may now feel abandoned and deeply disappointed. You may feel as though your prayers have gone unanswered and that God has let you down. God may seem distant, unreal and uninvolved. You may even reject God because you cannot accept that an all-loving and all-powerful God would ever have allowed you and your partner to suffer so much grief and pain.

At times, you may feel intense anger. If you have trusted in God all of your life, you may feel this anger most acutely : anger with God’s apparent indifference, anger that God has allowed such waste and such pain. You may have wept and screamed in anger with God after you lost your baby in spite of all your prayers for a healthy pregnancy. This is not shocking as anger, bewilderment and dismay with God are all common reactions to loss.

Even if you claim that you don’t believe in God, or are unsure about God’s existence, you may feel angry : anger that God doesn’t exist, anger that at the heart of the universe there is only suffering and pain, not love. If God is all-knowing, then God knows all your misery and how you feel. The danger comes when you are hurt but pretend you are not; when you feel deep bitterness and resentment, but decide to ignore it because you don’t want anyone to know how much pain you feel. The danger also comes when you feel guilty that you are so angry with God. You may try to prevent God from knowing how you feel, but if God is all-knowing, then there is no need to try and mask your grief. You may feel that when you do pour out your anger to God, you are released from much of your hurt. You may then feel that God begins to bring healing, and comfort, and eventually peace. You may no longer feel as though God is distant or unreal, but instead, intimately concerned with all that goes on in our world.

The Bible pictures a God whom is deeply involved in our suffering. This God is compassionate, grieves with us and longs for our peace. You may feel as though God understands how it feels to be bereaved, because God experienced deep suffering, separation and loss when death cut off the Father from his Son, Jesus, when he was crucified on the cross.

As grieving parents, you may be struggling relentlessly to answer every “why” question about your baby’s death. You may believe that if you can understand it, then you can accept it. Despite many theological and philosophical attempts, no one can really explain why tragic events occur. Sometimes they just happen and we will never know why in our lifetimes. However, acceptance of your baby’s death often comes in the absence of all the answers.


REMEMBERING THE BABY YOU HAVE LOST

You may wish to do something to mark the brief life of your baby in order to try and help you to accept your loss and start to move on. Creating a memorial to your lost baby may seem appropriate, even while your feelings are still very raw. You may like to plant flowers or a special tree or shrub as a symbol of your baby’s life spirit or as an expression of your love. A toy or item of clothing intended for your baby may become a special keepsake. It may be possible to arrange for the hospital chaplain, or representative of your own Christian denomination to give a short service, blessing or say a prayer for your baby. You may wish to see if you can place a marker in your local cemetery even though you may have no remains to bury. Some hospitals arrange regular services of remembrance and you may want to ask them for details. Your parish or nearest cathedral may have a Book of Remembrance where you may find it comforting to write a prayer, poem or a letter to your baby to express your thoughts and feelings. You may wish to keep a record of your thoughts and feelings in a diary as some people find that such words are healing and of tremendous comfort later on. You may wish to do something practical such as giving a donation to, or raising funds for, a charity such as the Miscarriage Association.

Historically, the Christian faith has offered little support for couples suffering with the pain of miscarriage. Thankfully, over recent years, this has started to change and some denominations will now add your baby’s name to the church registry of births and deaths. However, as many Christian leaders still underestimate the grief of losing of an unborn child you may feel disappointed at the lack of spiritual support within your church or Christian community. You may tell your priest, vicar or other leader of your Christian denomination about your miscarriage, yet no mention is made of the loss of your baby at a mass or service. No chance is given for others who are our brothers and sisters in Christ to offer prayer, comfort and support. You may feel that it is as if your baby never existed. As Christians, we claim to be pro-life, but our actions do not always follow it through to its logical conclusion. There still needs a lot to be done in order to educate everyone to the fact that the loss of a child in the womb causes tremendous grief and pain. Until the Christian churches understand this vital point then all the pro-life efforts are only half-hearted.

It is for this reason that memorials to the unborn have recently started to be set up:

  • In the Catholic cathedral in Liverpool, the memorial is a freestanding candle which burns perpetually. At the base there is room for flowers as it was felt that it is important for people to be able to do something not only spiritually but also physically. The candle is located in and has become one of the focal points in the Children’s Chapel, and is dedicated to all stillborn, miscarried or aborted babies.
Contact information:           Metropolitan Cathedral of Christ the King
Cathedral House,
Mount Pleasant,
Liverpool,
L3 5TQ,
England.
Tel: + 44 (0)151 709 9222
Fax: + 44 (0) 151 708 7274
  • In Mount Noddy cemetery, East Grinstead, the local branch of the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children erected a memorial with the full support of the town council and the Miscarriage Association.
Contact information:           East Grimstead Town Council
East Court,
College Lane,
East Grimstead,
West Sussex,
RH19 3LT
England.

Tel: + 44 (0)1342 323636
Fax: + 44 (0) 1342 327823
Email: cemeterymanager@eastgrimstead.gov.uk
  •  In Cambridge, a city centre memorial garden in the grounds of the Catholic Church, Our Lady and the English Martyrs, has been planned. A monument will be the focal point with the following inscription : “For those whose lives knew no birth”. The message is deliberately ambiguous so that women who are suffering after an abortion will not feel singled out or judged and those who have miscarried can also find a focus for their grief.
Contact information:           The Catholic Rectory,
Hills Road,
Cambridge,
CB2 1JR,
England.
Tel: + 44 (0)1223 350787
Fax: + 44 (0) 1223 224860
  • St Paul the Apostle RC Church, Tintagel, Cornwall, offers an annual mass in thanksgiving for all children who have died from conception to three years old. All the parents and families will also be remembered in the mass and anyone can enter names in a miscarriage and infant loss memorial book.
Contact information:           St Paul the Apostle Catholic Church
Chy An Pronter,
Bossiney Road,
Tintagel
PL34 0AQ,
Cornwall,
England.
Tel & Fax: + 44 (0)1840770663
  • For those who use the internet, memorials to the unborn include many on-line versions. Here anyone – mother, father, grandparent- can easily place a written memorial to a child that has been lost. If you would like to leave a message on an internet memorial site you could try the following two sites:

You may even wish to approach your priest, vicar or other leader of your Christian denomination about setting up a support group, memorial book, memorial garden, monument or annual memorial service in your own local parish or community.


PRAYERS AFTER A MISCARRIAGE

My Lord, the baby is dead !

Why, my Lord – dare I ask why ? It will not hear the whisper of the wind or see the beauty of its parents’ face – it will not see the beauty of Your creation or the flame of a sunrise. Why, my Lord ?

“Why, My child – do you ask ‘why’ ? Well, I will tell you why

You see, the child lives. Instead of the wind he hears the sound of angels singing before My throne. Instead of the beauty that passes he sees everlasting Beauty – he sees My face. He was created and lived a short time so that the image of his parents imprinted on his face may stand before Me as their personal intercessor. He knows secrets of heaven unknown to men on earth. He laughs with a special joy that only the innocent possess. My ways are not the ways of man. I create for My Kingdom and each creature fills a place in that Kingdom that could not be filled by another. He was created for My joy and his parents’ merits. He has never seen pain or sin. He has never felt hunger or pain. I breathed a soul into a seed, made it grow and called it forth.”

I am humbled before you, my Lord, for questioning Your wisdom, goodness, and love. I speak as a fool – forgive me. I acknowledge Your sovereign rights over life and death. I thank You for the life that began for so short a time to enjoy so long an Eternity.

-Mother M. Angelica.

------------------------------

“Dear God”, we asked,
“Should we try to have another child ?
After our miscarriage, we are anxious and fearful about another pregnancy.
The pain of loss is too intense and we are afraid of another unhappy ending.”

And God answered :
“Your fears are expected and understandable.
You do not need to decide right away whether you want to have another child.
Do not feel pressured.
Give yourself and your partner a chance to grieve.
Give yourself time to make this decision.
Listen to your doctors.
Listen to your partner.
Listen to your heart.
Listen to me.
Then decide.”

------------------------------

Dear God,
People ask me how I am coping.
I’ve learned to smile in company.
I’ve learned to appear calm and even relaxed.
But this is not the real me.
It is a person that I watch going through the motions of living.
Inside, I’m still screaming, or else I’m just numb.
Sometimes the ache is so strong that my whole body is racked with pain.
The pain and the questions are often bound up together.
Why did I have to miscarry (again) ?
The questions chase around inside my mind.
I feel there ought to be answers.
I feel I am owed some explanations.
Yet no explanations come, and there seems to be nowhere to go to find any.
You alone know the reasons for our loss.
Help me to accept your mysterious ways and your divine plan for me, which may differ from my human hopes and dreams.
Help us to understand that at the very heart of the universe there is not despair but hope, not evil but a God of love.
Amen.
------------------------------

My life is but a weaving between my Lord and me
I cannot see the colours He worketh steadily.
Oft times He weaveth sorrow and I in foolish pride
Forget He sees the upper and I the underside.

Not till the looms are silent and the shuttles cease to fly
Shall God unroll the canvas and explain the reason why.
The dark threads are as needful in the Weaver’s skilful hands
As the threads of gold and silver in the pattern He has planned.

------------------------------

Patron Saints against miscarriages:
  • Catherine of Siena
  • Catherine of Sweden
  • Eulalia


Written by Jane Parkinson

Any comments or suggestions on how to improve this article would be gratefully appreciated.
e-mail address: janefparkinson@hotmail.com



 

Create a free website at Webs.com 

©Jane Parkinson 2004